I recently ordered a coin ( pillar dollar 8 reale silver dated 1751, for $375.00 supposedly in Extra Fine rated condition) What they sent me the first time was an inferior coin that wasn't close to the quality that was pictured on the website, I sent back the inferior coin and gave them a chance to send an equal quality coin as shown or the actual coin that was pictured on the website, the replacement coin was worse than the first coin they sent, I returned the second inferior coin and asked for them to cover my shipping /insuring costs (approx. $21.00) they refused, I called several times to speak to management and supervisors about the ripoff to no avail! I want to warn everyone from purchasing coins or collectables from this unscrupulous "dealer". I gave them 3 chances in total to send me an extra fine rated coin as described and pictured on their site and they sent me GARBAGE! don't waste your time or money dealing with this company! They still have the coin I wanted and expected to receive on the site at a higher price now ($399.00) and I am sure what they would send an honest buyer another of their inferior coins worth considerably less than the quality coin they show you. Both replacement coins they sent to me were poor quality, heavily worn, and discolured, I think the rating they apply to their "merchandise is rated by their own "self appointed authority". One of the coins they sent me was cracked to boot! DON'T BE FOOLED AND DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME AND MONEY WITH THESE LOSERS.

Additional

Comment Instructions:

Author Comments: Author can add to report or amend report. Also can respond to other comments. (Report author must be logged it to use this feature)

Rebuttal is for the reported party to respond to the report. (You must be logged in to use this feature)

General Comments is for the general public to leave comment and feedback about the report. (Login not required)

Author's Comments

Rebuttal: You must be logged in

General Comments (Public)

steve greer,

coast to coast riped me off to. They sold me a stone mountian half dollar and said it was gem grade, when I sent it to be graded it came back with a no grade because it had been cleaned

2009-06-03 16:32:21

steve greer,

coast to coast riped me off to. They sold me a stone mountian half dollar and said it was gem grade, when I sent it to be graded it came back with a no grade because it had been cleaned ,also bought three walking liberty half dollars in BU and sent them for grading they all came back ,you know already, no grade

2009-06-03 16:37:58

cavy,

Here are two obvious nitwits who have done business
with a company they HATE...more than once.

Everytning I have received ftom this company has been equal to, or above stated quality.

Ignore dumb asses.

2009-11-04 17:03:40

Jenvy,

Cavy- I'm with you on this one. I have enjoyed doing business with this company for quite a while now...Maybe these two above us are just beginning to collect...

2009-11-28 06:31:38

John,

Bought several items from them. Never had a problem. Everyone has an opinion. I never judge something without trying it myself.

2009-12-24 22:08:09

B.P..L,

I've been ordering from this company for over a year now. I have had a couple of problens(late shipment, wrong coin)but problems were taken care of in a timely maner and I was refunded the cost of shipping on the item returned. I will keep ordering as time goes on.

2010-01-01 21:33:48

marc,

i ordered a lot of gold and recently proof dollars and halves. also foreign silver coins, etc. the only coin i didn't think measured up was a 1500-1600 hungarian Madonna and Child for $7.
their proofs are much better than some i got from ebay. coast to coast always gives excellent service.

2010-01-11 19:13:05

rdcuff,

I have done business with this company at least 6 times in the past and never had a problem

2010-01-23 21:06:18

retrpd95,

I have done business with Coast to Coast for over 5 years. Everything I have purchased has been equal to or above advertised quality. I have been collecting and selling coins for 39 years so I am not new to this. Remember one thing, you get what you pay for, hole fillers or high end coins. Your not going to buy a 1907 Double Eagle in MS64 for $250! But you might buy a 2.5 gold Indian in AU for that price.
So, just think before you spend that freshly printed funny Obama money and purchase something of real value, silver and gold and older coins!

2010-02-03 12:26:18

thgdriver,

I have bought thousands of dollars in coins and paper money from Coast To Coast coins over the last six years. In fact, I use their catalog as a guide when buying on E-Bay. I returned a 1928 Redeemable in Gold FRN 20.00 in all that time. A prompt apology and refund was quickly given. I just ordered my 2010 Silver Eagles from them.

2010-02-07 09:46:57

grumpy,

no problems here bought from them over 10 years.just bought 2010 eagles,will continue

2010-02-26 18:00:47

mathias berry,

i have been buying and selling coins from coast to coast for over 20 years .all the coins that i bought were better than i expected all the coins that i sold them ,i got top dollar about 30% more than i could get locally

2010-03-24 23:09:21

Jimmee beem,

I have been dealing with coast to coast for a few years now and will say they are a fair company! I haven`t had any problems dealing with them,one time they sent me an incorrect coin,but they promptly corrected the problem! And might I add they are always courteous and nice on the phone.!

2010-04-18 17:39:10

steve,

I have purchased coins a couple times from coast to coast coins, but received 1 to 2 grades less than they advertised. not happy. Had same bad experience with L and C coins also. Better off buying coins from a reputable dealer or coin shows. Occasionally on Ebay, where the seller is well established with high quality photo,s.

2010-04-18 22:08:36

DONALD,

I HAVE MUCH SILVER AND MANY COMPLETED COLLECTIONS.I HAVE AT LEAST SENT WELL OVER 11,000 DOLLARS TO THEM IN ONLY THE LAST 3 YEARS,YOUR NEGATIVE VIEWS OF THIS HIGHLY RESPECTED COMPANY INSTANTLY AND ACCURATELY PROVES YOU PEOPLE DO NOT KNOW ***** FROM APPLEBUTTER ABOUT COIN COLLECTING AND IF I MAY BE SO BOLD AS TO RECOMEND THAT YOU DUDES NEED TO COLLECT STUFF YOU CAN BUY AT A GARAGE SALE OR DOLLAR GENERAL.

2010-06-02 20:16:02

Bruce Walker,

I have only ordered a few items from Coast to Coast, but with good results. In particular, a recent gold 1916-s Half-Eagle graded AU58 by NGC for $475 which I felt was extremely competitively priced. Had a flawless portrait, the cheek was fully as struck. Just a hint of contact on the fields, arguably an MS62 as the grades around MS60 are not consistent from any of the grading services. A much better dated and mint marked coin for only $50 more than a common date example. As larger dealers go, I consider them the best.

2010-09-01 21:52:55

Tools

(Public) Username:
Password:
Forgot password? Register